Who is Snoke? Don’t care, doesn’t matter

In deference to those who found it puzzling that The Last Jedi didn’t give us more on The Force Awakens‘ Big Bad, I concede that we’re entitled to wonder whether Snoke was a Sith, and if so, how he fits into the always-two-there-are model. One might profitably muse on whether Sith-ness is in fact constrained to the always-two-there-are model, or whether that was just a story Plagueis/Palpatine, Palpatine/Dooku, then Palpatine/Vader told to make themselves feel special.

What I don’t concede is that the film has to explore that. I rather think we’ll have more fun speculating on such things ourselves that we would get from being told the what The Answer is. Because whatever The Answer turns out to be, the only possible response will be “oh”.

What’s much more important than Snoke’s origin/identity is Kylo Ren’s journey. Some may ask questions like:

If Snoke is a Sith, is Kylo Ren his apprentice? Or has Ren independently decided to revive Granddad’s cult? If Ren doesn’t see himself as the continuation of the Sith, in what sense does he think he’s the new Darth Vader? (But why hasn’t he taken on the title Darth?)

I think the defining characteristic of Kylo Ren is that he doesn’t know what the heck he’s doing. He pretty explicitly started out as a Vader fanboy (“I will finish what you started, grandfather”), just like any other edgy teen who is drawn to big-R Romantic notions of darkness. The only difference is that instead of sublimating this into making a collection of Judas Priest LPs, Ben Solo has enough innate Force ability to parlay his really slightly laughable obsession into something genuinely dangerous.

Subsequently, he is obviously fascinated by the idea of turning away from this path to return to Han — both compelled and repelled — but in the end he is too much in fear or in awe of Snoke to do it. Yet when the chance comes, he kills Snoke in a completely unpremeditated moment. He’s thinking with his hormones, not his brain — by which I don’t just mean whatever kind of affection he has for Rey, but more broadly the whole wash of mutually confusing and contradictory adolescent hormones. At any moment, he could go either way — as when, immediately after Snoke’s death, he and Rey fight joyously side by side, only for the moment of camaraderie to dissolve the moment the Red Guards are defeated.

Ben Solo is a kid who is fascinated by Nazi memorabilia, first excited then horrified to find he actually has it in him to create a Fourth Reich, and now winging it from moment to moment.

Isn’t all of this tremendously more interesting than one more This Is Your Destiny journey?

[Note: this post is adapted from a comment that I left on Andrew Rilstone’s blog.]

3 responses to “Who is Snoke? Don’t care, doesn’t matter

  1. Maarten Daalder

    I agree, but I also wouldn’t be surprised if Snoke turns out to be alive and well, and the Snoke that we saw being cut down was just a more advanced form of astral projection. And that would mean that it all could still be according to Snoke’s plans.

  2. The Last Jedi is probably the most interesting movie I saw all year. For once, I could never be sure what was going to happen. I thought the movie played with its legacy brilliantly as well.

    I honestly enjoyed the previous one as well. Many people got hung up on “yet another death star”, but it’s just a McGuffin… might as well be a death star. My opinion at the time was that it was either inoffensively fun, or just good setup depending on what would come after. This movie seems to vindicate the second opinion, but the third movie will truly make or break the series.

    You never know, but I hope Snoke doesn’t come back, but we still get some insight into his relation with Kylo (the truly interesting thing about him, just like the interesting thing about the emperor was how he played Anakin like a fiddle).

  3. Pingback: A few thoughts on The Rise of Skywalker | The Reinvigorated Programmer

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.