Credit where it’s due: Children of Earth

I just want to post this brief note as a counterbalance to my recent post on How much I hate Torchwood.  Despite the delay described in that post, I did slog through to the end of the Series 2, and it was just as risible as I’d feared — I mean, astonishingly shallow and childish, appallingly written and dreadfully acted.

So I went into Series 3 (Children of Earth) with low expectations.  But having now seen the first three of the five episodes, I have to admit it’s much, much better than I’d dared hope.  Each of these three episodes has been far better than anything in either of the first two series.

Four things seem have happened.

First, the writers have finally wrapped their heads around what makes something “adult” — that it doesn’t just mean Snogging ‘N’ Swearing, but the careful use of tension and release to build into a story with real substance, even complexity, whose twists are unforeseen yet arise organically from what has gone before.

Second, the general level of the acting has gone up a couple of notches — partly because Owen is finally gone so that we no longer have to suffer through Burn Gorman’s plastic performances; partly because Captain Jack is kept offscreen for much of the time, so that John Barrowman’s inadequacies are less painfully apparent.  Instead, we see much more of Gwen and Rhys, and of Ianto and his family, all of whom are much more naturalistic and believable.  They behave as though they’re in a drama rather than a pantomime.

Third, there is much less reliance on special effects — and the effects in Torchwood have always been unconvincing, so that every time they come on screen, they make it hard to suspend disbelief.  In Children of Earth, the sci-fi/supernatural elements are mostly portrayed simply by acting, and they are all the better for it.

Finally, and maybe most important, the format of five tightly interwoven episodes suits Torchwood much better than the usual approach of thirteen essentially standalone episodes.  There is time for the ideas to live and breathe, for concepts to emerge gradually, for the minor characters to develop into people that we can care about, for real tension to develop as the nature of the threat gradually becomes apparent.

Taken together, these changes make a huge difference to the experience of watching, lifting a programme that I’d previously been watching out of sheer bloody-mindedness up to the level of a mid-to-good Doctor Who episode.  And I mean that as very high praise.  I even laughed out loud during episode 2 (at the line “we want a pony”), which is something I’ve never done before while watching Torchwood, except when laughing at the programme.  And the cliffhanger at the end of episode 3 truly came as a shock.

So I just hope it keeps up the same high standard in the last two episodes — and that the whole, when I’ve seen it all, is at least equal to the sum of its parts.

5 responses to “Credit where it’s due: Children of Earth

  1. Yes – it’s like someone had watched some old episodes of Quatermass, then merged them with the kind of political drama that the BBC have always done well. It has ‘cosmic horror’, and a menace that RTD has always been reluctant to build-up.

    Unfortunately, Miracle Day isn’t holding up to the same standard, so far. Better than series 1 and 2, but you can see the obvious ‘Well 24 and Alias are popular programs, so what we need is lots of double-crossing American intelligence officers. And women wearing improbable heels for the jobs they are doing.

  2. I recently re-watched Torchwood as preparation for the new series. Series 3 ‘Children of Earth’ is a superb TV story, plenty of twists, well-paced and clever mix of humour and horror. Even though I knew how it ended, I found myself gripped by the story again and would happily watch it again.

  3. WyrdestGeek

    That’s cool. Maybe I’ll check out Torchwood series 3 sometime then. Thanks for the reconnaissance! :-)

    Furry cows moo and decompress.

  4. Pingback: Children of Earth: the final verdict, part 1: why Torchwood sucks | The Reinvigorated Programmer

  5. Pingback: Children of Earth: the final verdict, part 2: how Torchwood stopped sucking | The Reinvigorated Programmer

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.